I am a big fan of the brown spectrum of lenses, and not just to throw a wrench out there on this topic. Brown and green lenses reduce the blue color spectrum, of which the water and sky is in your face while fishing. I started out with USAF Rayban G15 green, then the G15 or G34 brown lenses and I now use Berkely browns (with readers) and they are the best for me on the water.
My caveat is I only see with one eye, which is very light sensitive, and which needs to be protected all the time. So, geeky clear safety glasses at night and nerdy polarized yellows for rainy days.
Best thing would be to try before you buy, hand over your drivers license and walk around a parking lot on a bright sunny day looking into windshield relections, with whatever glasses you think might work for you.